Nicole Hardy June 12th, 2024

Creativity Crisis: Why Is AI Bad for Original Thinking in Writing?

AI has influenced all industries, and the creative realm is no exception, including writing. While AI tools promise efficiency and a break from the drudgery of repetitive tasks, they also bring up a big question: Are we sacrificing creativity for convenience? 

It's essential to explore how AI tools might reshape the writing craft, and not always for the better. There's something special about a piece crafted by a human essay writer that AI can't replicate. For students seeking help with their essays, a human writer's personal touch, nuanced understanding, and creative flair are irreplaceable. AI might be able to generate a complete essay on a given topic rapidly, but can it engage a reader's emotions or offer original ideas as effectively? Let's dive into the heart of this discussion.

AI and Writing: The Impact on Creativity 

You've probably noticed how some content nowadays feels a bit... off. That's because they're crafted by AI, which only repeats what's already out there. The reliability of information is another concern. A 2023 study revealed that heavy reliance on AI for writing tasks reduces the accuracy of the results by 25.1%. How does AI write? AI tools analyze huge chunks of existing texts to produce content. While this can make writing faster, it also means the content can end up looking and sounding the same. Where's the fun in reading something that feels like deja vu?

When writers lean too much on AI, they risk dulling their ability to think originally and expressively. For students, this is particularly risky. This is why AI is bad for education. Schools are supposed to be playgrounds for the mind, places where you can experiment with ideas and find your voice. If AI does too much of the work, students might miss out on developing these crucial skills. 

Challenges to Original Thinking

AI tools are gaining popularity fast. In early 2023, ChatGPT set a record by reaching over 100 million monthly users in just two months after launch. While it has some undeniable advantages, this surge in the popularity of AI tools has caused certain challenges as well. 

Dilution of Personal Expression

AI is all about algorithms, which means it loves patterns. But great writing isn’t just about sticking to patterns—it’s about breaking them sometimes. AI’s tendency to standardize could mean your next essay sounds like everyone else's. Remember, the most memorable pieces of writing are those that reflect a unique perspective, something that AI just can't mimic.

Homogenization of Writing Styles

And it’s not just your voice that’s at risk. As more people use AI tools, there’s a tendency for all writing to start sounding similar. Think about it: if everyone uses the same tool, doesn’t it make sense that everyone’s output might start to look the same? This doesn’t just stifle individuality; it could flatten the entire landscape of literary styles, turning vibrant variety into boring uniformity.

Reduction in Critical Thinking

Here's a not-so-fun fact: when AI takes over the brainy bits of writing, you might disengage from the process. How does AI affect writers? It's easy to become passive, watching as the AI assembles your thoughts. This is especially bad news for students, who need to flex their mental muscles by tackling complex writing tasks. Critical thinking is like a muscle—if you don't use it, you lose it.

Broader Implications

When AI scripts the show, the range of voices in literature might begin to narrow. Diversity in writing isn't just about different themes or genres; it’s about different ways of seeing the world. If AI keeps us locked into a certain way of writing, we might start missing out on those fresh, exciting perspectives that come from real human experiences.

Looking ahead, the impact of AI on professional writing careers looks equally concerning. How is AI affecting education? Will future writers need to conform to AI standards to succeed? If so, we might see a drop in the quality and variety of professional writing as the push for AI efficiency overtakes the need for human creativity and insight.

AI in Education and How It Affects Academic Writing 

Let's take a look at a real example. In some classrooms, AI is bad for education because students use AI to polish their essays. At first glance, these essays look perfect. However, over time, teachers notice something troubling—the students' work begins to lack depth and originality. They're not learning to craft arguments or express unique ideas. Instead, they're just learning to edit what AI produces. It's a bit like painting by numbers: the end result might look good, but the process isn't creative.

For learners, the stakes are high. Why is AI bad for students? Learning to write creatively is not just an academic exercise—it’s a way to learn how to think, argue, and persuade. If AI starts doing too much of this work, students could end up with a cookie-cutter education that fails to inspire or challenge them. What’s the point of learning to write if you’re not learning to think?

Alternative Approaches and Solutions

To keep AI in its rightful place as a tool rather than a replacement, writers need to focus on developing their own skills alongside the technology. Use AI to handle the repetitive parts of writing, like checking grammar, but make sure the ideas and the voice are unmistakably yours.

Schools and colleges have a crucial role to play in combating the negative effects of AI in education. They should encourage curricula that value creativity and individuality over the ability to use tools. Besides, online essay writer services can also help, offering students nuanced writing support. It’s about teaching students how to use technology wisely, enhancing their skills without overshadowing them.

Lastly, never underestimate the importance of the human touch. Writers need to stay in the driver's seat, using AI as a navigator rather than letting it take the wheel. This means always being ready to question, modify, and ultimately oversee the content that AI helps produce, ensuring that each piece of writing reflects true human thought and creativity.


As we look toward the future, it's clear that AI will change many aspects of our lives, but here's the good news: AI will not replace writers. The essence of writing—conveying emotion, capturing the human experience, and sparking imagination—is inherently human. No matter how advanced AI gets, the depth, emotion, and personal touch you bring to your writing are yours alone. So use AI, but make every piece you write your own.

Featured Image by Parker Byrd on Unsplash

Nicole Hardy

Nicole Hardy is a writing expert with a passion for teaching and a dedication to preserving the art of creative expression. She emphasizes the importance of maintaining personal voice and originality in the face of advancing AI technologies. Her articles offer thoughtful commentary on how writers can navigate the digital age while staying true to their authentic selves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *