Sep 22 2011

The 21 Greatest SEO Myths of the Modern World

Advertisement

They say that ignorance is bliss and knowledge is power but somewhere between these clichés there’s a spot reserved for individuals who possess a little too much knowledge to be blissful but still only enough knowledge to be dangerous.

SEO, as an industry, is known unfortunately for the mass of rumours, myths, mistruths and unscrupulous gurus. This in part stems from the search engines’ unwillingness to discuss their algorithms (this lack of disclosure is completely understandable). This breeds a culture of myths where newbies and veterans alike get caught out by nothing more than hearsay that gains traction.

The aim of this post is to try and dispel some of the more widely held SEO myths:

#1 – Google is the Only Search Engine


Google may be the largest search engine but you shouldn’t ignore the others. Image Credit

It sounds ridiculous to say and whilst Google is the biggest of the search engines, Bing has certainly cornered a fair percentage of the market – some say as high as 30% of all US searches are powered by Bing. This means that while you should undoubtedly concentrate your SEO efforts on pandering to Google, you shouldn’t completely ignore Bing.

Many of the techniques and principles are the same across the search engines but you should also do things like register your website over at Bing’s Webmaster Center Tools.

#2 – You Need to Submit Your Website to Google

This is a myth that has been around as long as Alta Vista.

There are hundreds if not thousands of hosting companies, SEO companies and web designers offering to ‘submit’ your website to all the major search engines – and charge you for the privilege.

The fact is you just don’t need to submit your website to Google or any other search engine. Inclusion in search engines is free and usually automated. Google very often finds and indexes your website as a result of visiting a link contained on another web page.

#3 – You Can ‘SEO’ a Website Just Once

Search engine optimisation is rarely a one-time thing – we understand why people hope it is, since cash, particularly in small businesses, is precious. However, a website’s search engine performance needs regular attention.

This might sound like the plea of a salesman pitching a monthly retainer but the simple fact of the matter is that Google et al tweak their algorithms and search results constantly, not forgetting the fact that your competitors are likely to be investing in improving their websites too.

All of this can have a dramatic impact on your website’s performance in the search results. If you’re not investing in SEO on a regular basis then you’re falling behind.

#4 – You don’t need to worry about SEO

There are some people who will tell you to completely disregard SEO, saying that they’ve never given a fig about the search engines in their life and they’ve done alright.

Granted, some brands, rockstars and superstar bloggers can get away with not bothering. For everyone else however, optimising your website and working towards better search engine visibility is essential. Whilst you shouldn’t do things or make decisions solely on the basis of search engines, you should certainly contemplate them and understand how they work and what they look for because they are a truly astounding source of traffic.

#5 – Your Rankings Don’t Matter

The advent of personalised search results has reduced the importance of rankings somewhat but they aren’t obsolete by any means. They may not give you a 100% accurate picture but they are a fair indication or approximation of where your website ranks for the majority of users.

We understand why this myth came to be, and we accept that any SEO worth their salt should be focusing their attention on more than just rankings these days; overall search visibility, conversion rate and search engine traffic are core success metrics in many’s eyes.

But don’t forget that the lion-share of searchers will leave Google via the first page of results so knowing where your website sits is a very useful indicator indeed.

#6 – An XML Sitemap Will Boost Your Rankings

We imagine this started life as the perfectly legitimate advice that having a sitemap is a good idea from an SEO perspective – it certainly is a best practice.

However, whispers across forums and blogs likely transformed this into the myth that a sitemap would boost your rankings. The suggestion that a sitemap will give any page on your website a boost is pure fiction – search engines use your sitemap to learn about the structure of your site and to increase coverage of your webpages.

#7 – Keyword Domains Trump All Other Tactics


Keyword domains don’t hold the same power as they once did. In fact, the idea is somewhat dated. Image Credit

In case you are wondering, a keyword domain is a domain that includes a keyword you wish to target, for example cheapwidgets.com.

Registering a keyword domain was, at one time, a reasonable SEO strategy (not one that we favoured, but nobody can deny that it worked) however since Matt Cutts announced in 2010 that Google would be looking into why keyword domains rank so well and the search engine’s subsequent ‘tuning down’ of the power of keyword domains, this has become a far less effective strategy.

We will accept that in some markets it will still work but this isn’t going to be the case for very long since in most verticals and particularly on competitive keywords, Google has all but wiped out the keyword domains that didn’t really deserve the rankings they had suggesting they’ve gotten wise to the tactic.

If you’re looking to establish a solid foundation for your website then it is far smarter to opt for a brandable and memorable domain rather than attempting to shoehorn your target keywords into a long, often hyphenated, difficult to remember and spammy looking domain.

To be clear, if you own a keyword domain, it’s not going to count against you, you just need to embark on a proper promotional campaign including link development and social media marketing in order to build the authority and profile of the website.

#8 – Copying a Competitor = A Strategy

There is a widely held belief that firing up OpenSiteExplorer and taking a look under the hood of your competitor’s website constitutes an SEO strategy – it really doesn’t.

Replicating your competitor’s link profile or search strategy is rarely a smart move and may even count against you. This is because a technique or linking method that works for them may not work the same way for you.

There’s nothing wrong with learning from your competitors, as the old saying goes “Learn from the mistakes that other people make” and with the wealth of data available, it is a smart move to understand what your competition is doing and develop your strategy accordingly.

#9 – Meta Data is Worthless

Less important, yes. But worthless? No.

We’ve seen Google ignore meta titles and descriptions when it thinks there is a better one to use but by and large it will take your hint as to what the page is about.

Wouldn’t you much rather your preferred title and description were used rather than what Google can pull from the page itself? Meta data is your chance to convince searchers to clickthrough – it is your platform to engage and standout.

With the launch of Google+, each time a link is published on the social network, a title and description is scraped. If your website doesn’t have any data then Google will pull in whatever it can find, and your link could end up looking pretty ugly.

#10 – You Can Learn SEO by Reading Up

In every industry there are ‘gurus’ and the world of SEO is no different – wannabe experts who’ve got their website ranking for a brand term and suddenly think they’re qualified to teach others “how to get page 1 rankings”.

There are some gurus out there who spend more time theorising, pontificating and regurgitating opinions of others than they do actually SEOing, consequently their knowledge and advice often leaves a little to be desired.

Be careful who you take advice from and try to divide your time 10/90 so for every 10 minutes you spend studying SEO you should spend 90 minutes actually doing it. The best way to learn SEO is to experiment yourself.

That’s not to say that there aren’t some sharp minds out there, in fact there are many SEO blogs out there worth checking out.

With Google’s recent announcement that they will support the rel author attribute, trust and authority will start to play a bigger role in SEO in the future. This should help to increase the visibility of the true experts out there – which will be a good thing for everyone.

#11 – Google Adwords Can Hurt/Help Your Rankings

There is a definite conspiracy theory that advertising via the Google Adwords platform somehow impacts on your organic search rankings. There seems to be just as many people who believe the exact opposite. That fact alone should tell you that there is absolutely no truth to this.

Nevertheless, it is a myth that continues to spread despite the fact that Google has reiterated time and time again that “Google’s advertising programs are entirely independent of the unpaid search results.” (source)

It is understandable why some people believe this to be a fact but in reality having worked on close to 250 campaigns (which included a mix of SEO and PPC), honestly, there is no visible correlation whatsoever between Google Adwords spending and organic rankings.

#12 – Google Will Never Figure Out What I’m Up To


Be very mindful of the footprint you are leaving… Image Credit

Google is very advanced – there are undoubtedly some areas they could improve on – but by and large as each year passes their algorithm gets smarter and smarter in order to deliver better and better results for users.

Find the balance; develop a strategy that gets the results you want without pushing it too far and earning yourself a penalty or worse still a ban.

Google is very quick to recognize patterns in linkbuilding for example; if they detect anything unnatural or untoward then you could be in for a nasty shock.

With the recent Panda update, Google has also advanced a great deal in the way it views content; it has certainly gotten better at identifying duplicate and thin content. One could even argue that Google, is now very close to ‘understanding’ what makes content high-quality, making the need to be an authority and true expert in your market an ever increasing necessity.

Be mindful of the footprint you are leaving – build for the long term where possible and if you are going to dabble in the edgier tactics then make sure you know what you’re doing.

#13 – Scraping is a Content Strategy

Despite all the recent Panda update noise in the online marketing world, there are still some webmasters out there that are scraping content.

If you don’t know what scraping content is then in essence it is a process whereby content is pinched from a website and republished on another.

Filling your website with other people’s unique content does not constitute a strategy; it will get your website flagged for spam probably faster than any other tactic.

We readily accept that sometimes scraped content outranks the original but this occurs more and more infrequently. To see scraping as a viable content creation technique is unethical, often illegal and just plain crazy.

Google and Bing actively encourage creating high-quality content and since the good stuff tends to be what attracts and engages real people then common sense tells us it will always be the best strategy.

#14 – Keyword Density Rules

We simply had to include this one. Despite this myth repeatedly being buried, keyword density always seems to find its way into the conscious minds of newbies and intermediates alike.

Back in the early days of search engines, there was a magical keyword density percentage that each page should fulfil in order to rank well. If things weren’t going well, you’d just add more keywords, simple.

The effectiveness of this technique died out a long time ago and yet we still see websites trying desperately hard to jump through a hoop that doesn’t exist.

Write for humans whilst interweaving keywords naturally into your text. Saturating your copy with keywords is a shortcut to switched-off visitors.

#15 – You Should Crank Out as Much Content as Possible


Creating content, unlike working on the factory floor, is not about sheer output quantity. Image Credit

There was a time where churning as much content out as possible was an arguably effective strategy. Want to target a new keyword? Just create a new page, rehash the text from a closely related page and Bob’s your uncle; you’ve got some extra-long tail search traffic.

However, since Google rolled out their Panda update (which they’ve labeled a high-quality sites algorithm) they issued some guidance as to what they expect high-quality might look like.

They published some questions that help you to better understand Google’s mindset when they set out the aims of the Panda update. One of these questions was:
“Does the site have duplicate, overlapping, or redundant articles on the same or similar topics with slightly different keyword variations?”

This is a direct attack on the aforementioned strategy and gives you all the more reason to consolidate your unruly content archive into a neatly organised, engaging and informative series of knowledge hubs – your visitors will love you for it too.

Publish content that adds value for the end user rather than content designed solely to feed search engine spiders – the spiders have lost their appetite for junk.

#16 – There’s an Ideal Wordcount

We can’t say for sure the actual origins of this myth but the truth is that there really isn’t a wordcount requirement for SEO.

If you produce a piece that is too short then you run the risk of not covering the topic in enough detail which can be a turn off for the people reading it and can also be a turn off for the search engines.

If you produce a piece that is too long then you run the risk of it being perceived as boring or un-readable which will have a negative impact on the social/viral capabilities of the piece – which could have a knock-on effect to your rankings. A long and boring piece of content may also prove a complete turn-off to visitors who immediately leave your website; this ‘bounceback effect’ will impact on user data which Google then reworks back into how it ranks your website.

The answer is that you should produce content that is just right – no need to worry about how many words it is, just cover what needs to be covered, edit and proofread it then publish it in a user-friendly format.

#17 – It’s All About Great Content

We truly wish we could tell you that Google and Bing were smart enough to recognise great content alone –we could all build fantastic websites and people would flock to our doors to devour our content.

Sadly, we’re not quite there yet and whilst high-quality content is a big (and ever-growing) part of SEO, it isn’t the whole shebang. You’ll still need to get involved in other areas if you are going to succeed in the search results.

Having an attention strategy for your website and content is paramount to SEO – without it, any time or resources invested in content will potentially be wasted.

#18 – PageRank is the Only Metric That Matters

Google has long been telling us not to obsess over PageRank (PR) and yet many continue to do so. It just isn’t the metric it once was.

Sure, it is interesting as a concept to understand and it’s interesting to know the published PageRank (See myth #19) of your own website but don’t judge everything you do by PR.

There are over 200 ranking factors that Google uses to determine where your website appears in the search results, PageRank is one of them and is therefore only a very small part of your website’s performance.

When it comes to building links, it can be easy to get drunk on the PageRank as you seek out ‘high-PR’ websites to attain links from but remember that there is more to a link than its PageRank; think traffic, neighbourhood, context, type and position to name but a few link quality metrics.

#19 – Toolbar PageRank and PageRank Are the Same Thing

To many, PageRank is PageRank but in actual fact it has long been accepted that there is a published PageRank, often referred to as toolbar PageRank, and an internal PageRank which Google uses behind closed doors and doesn’t actually publish.

Toolbar PageRank, inherited the name because of its appearance in the Google toolbar, is actually a snapshot of internal PageRank data so is very often out of date since it is only updated intermittently throughout the year.

This added confusion helps to reinforce the point that you shouldn’t ever see PageRank as the king of all metrics.

#20 – Quantity of Links is What Matters


Building links isn’t just a numbers game, it’s a metrics game – relevance and quality are more important. Image Credit

This myth stems from the principle that a link was a vote for your website and therefore the more votes (links) your website got; the more popular it must be and therefore should rank higher.

Sadly, not all links are created equal.

We can see why some people are quantity obsessed when it comes to links because as consumers we have been brainwashed to assess value by volume; big household brands have drummed into us that more = better. However when it comes to building links, it’s the quality that counts.

#21 – No-follow = Not Worth It

The no-follow attribute provides a way for webmasters to tell search engines not to follow any links on a page or a specific link on that page.

It tells the search engines that you don’t editorially vouch for the website you are linking out to and therefore no anchor text, PageRank or any of your website’s authority should be passed on. No-follow is in essence contraception for links.

This has led to the widely held belief that a link that is no-follow is not valuable. In my opinion, links that are no-follow are still valuable for two reasons:

Many leading websites no-follow their links but the traffic and exposure opportunities alone still make the link worthwhile.

Furthermore, it wouldn’t be unreasonable to assume that search engines assess how natural your link profile looks and since generally speaking a website will pick up some no-follow links naturally, it would look wholly suspicious if your link profile consists only of do-follow links. (See myth #12)

The fact is that search engines and their algorithms evolve all the time but the fundamental principles remain almost the same – create a high quality website that delights, engages and provides value to an audience whether that be your readers or your customers.

That is All

So that does it for this myth-busting look at the world of SEO. What SEO myths have you heard that were not discussed? Which of the myth-busting dissections do you disagree with? Have you fallen victim to any of these myths before? Hit us up in the comments and let us know!

(rb)

About the Author

James Agate is the Founder and Head of Search at Skyrocket SEO - an international, high-performance SEO consultancy. James contributes to a number of leading blogs and online publications on the topic of SEO. Follow James on Twitter

Homepage

Comments and Discussions
  • Nat, 22 September 2011

    SEO is the school of humility, what will work for a site will not be relevant to another site, so you have to continually test and adapt strategies in the long term.

  • danjay, 22 September 2011

    Cheers bro,

    Still can’t believe how much there is to the whole shebang .. trying to please the Panda =)

  • David, 22 September 2011

    This is a great article. It’s a nice piece to send along to new marketing staff or that occasional exec who wants to give this “internet marketing thing” a try for awhile. You would be amazed at how often I still bump into #2.

    • James Agate, 22 September 2011

      Thanks David, I still see companies offering to submit to Google all the time. We recently had a small business client who had paid £79.95 to be submitted to Google via their hosting company – outrageous. I’d love to get this piece in front of as many people as possible for their sake really! :-)

      James

  • Iain, 22 September 2011

    These points all make sense and whilst they may be simply understood to be true by those of us working in SEO, newcomers and dabblers will find the information invaluable.

    For the rest of us, it’s sometimes good to find that others concur with our thoughts. It’s also a very nicely written piece.

    Good work.

    • James Agate, 22 September 2011

      Thanks Iain, I agree…sometimes it is good to go back to basics because ‘experts’ so often just want to cover the groundbreaking, thought-leadership stuff, forgetting that some people just aren’t up to speed with them yet.

      That is what I was hoping to achieve with this piece.

      James

  • Rana mukherjee, 22 September 2011

    Awesome

  • Nice collection! Couldn’t agree more.

  • Kulwant Nagi, 22 September 2011

    SEO is step by step process. No one can come to first page just in one Night.. Unique Content and Regular Posting is the Key to Improve SEO. No Third party can help you to come on first page. what they will do is to add some good keywords to your site. All these things you can do yourself also but it will take some time..
    Thanks For this good Information..

  • Janine, 22 September 2011

    The SEO world is full of myths (and bullshit)! Sometimes it’s better to start with a SEO book instead of reading all different opinions online…

  • Shropshire, 22 September 2011

    Google may not be the only search engine*, but if you can get a first page SERP in Google I can’t see how you could not get a first page SERP in Yahoo or Bing. Their search algorithms are a lot easier to work with and predict than dealing with Panda.

    * though according to statcounter.com, Bing/Yahoo count for 19% of searches in the US and 9% in the UK.

  • Jen, 22 September 2011

    Thank you so much for the myth busting! Since I have just ventured into SEO I am lucky to not be tainted by many of the SEO optimization myths because everything I have sought out about SEO is relatively recent. This list is still invaluable, however, as social proof of the myths when it comes to convincing others that things have changed. I also particularly appreciated the reminder that Google isn’t the only search engine. Good thing to remember!

  • Climax Media, 22 September 2011

    BOOM! That’s the sound of popular belief being shattered :) Fantastic list of misunderstood SEO practices. This content would make a great infographic… Hint, hint…

    • James Agate, 23 September 2011

      Thanks for the hint – I’ll see what the Noupe guys think to this :-)

  • Mikey, 22 September 2011

    I hardly ever comment on blogs but this piece was just right – informative, clear and engaging. It’s very easy to get sucked into these types of myth – so many people expect shortcuts to success when the reality is that we need to put the hard work in first.

    Thank you.

  • Nima Heydarian, 22 September 2011

    The one that used to get me was thinking that good content is enough. It’s not.

  • Ash Menon, 22 September 2011

    I once had a client that asked me how much I would charge to get her business up to first place in Google. When I asked her for what search, she said for any search. I explained to her the concept of keywords, and she complied by writing down a list of keywords she wanted to rank for. “health” was one of them.

    This is actually quite a well-summarized article. I think I shall link future clients to this page if they come to me with SEO misconceptions.

    • James Agate, 23 September 2011

      Happy to be of service Ash!

  • Niki Pike, 22 September 2011

    Thanks for the great article James. As a web designer/developer it always makes me laugh hearing what my clients consider SEO. It seems everyone thinks they are masters as this. It’s great to have an article that puts an end to so many rumors.
    As with anything involving the web or the internet, our business is ever changing. If you think you can sit still with out evolving, you will get lost in the dust.

  • Andi Hnida, 22 September 2011

    Thank you for your article. It’s a good thing to know what’s worth to spend your time on. When doing SEO there is plenty time to waste. The thing with content is that users will notice sooner or later, that a page / blog is just not worth it.

    Keep up the work!

  • Nick Fisher, 23 September 2011

    Great article, very informative.

    I’m a beginning developer and this certainly shed some light on the dark dirty subject of SEO.

    Thank you James!

  • Jeffrey, 23 September 2011

    Awesome post! All these myths are blown out of proportion by wannabe gurus. Thank you for dispelling these myths and giving some rock solid content on how they are a load of hogwash!

  • Designerist, 23 September 2011

    Thanks for this comprehensive, very in detail article. I will study it thoroughly and share it with my teammates!

  • JB, 23 September 2011

    Really interesting read. Great evidence to back up the myths. The Panda update has put a stop to a lot of points that agencies push on clients.

  • Jim of the North, 23 September 2011

    Wow, an SEO article by someone who actually knows what they’re talking about!? Nicely done, thanks for a good read!

    • James Agate, 24 September 2011

      Thanks Jim – honoured to fall into that category! :-)

  • Greg Montoya, 23 September 2011

    I will definetly forward this to my SEO clients who arent really educated on the matter. Love the design of your site also… Its insane. Anyways keep up the good articles.

  • Google-ite, 26 September 2011

    “Google may be the largest search engine but you shouldn’t ignore the others.” which is funny since the article mentions Google 30+ times (not counting the first two points) compared to the >5 times Bing is mentioned

    • Robert Bowen, 26 September 2011

      Actually, it’s not funny at all. It just shows that since Google has been around so much longer, there is a lot more misinformation out there about them that needs to be cleared up. ;)

      • Google-ite, 26 September 2011

        I didn’t mean that statement was funny or incorrect. I meant it was funny that the article starts out with that as the first point but makes little reference to the other search engines with things that i.e. Bing does.
        “We’ve seen Google ignore meta titles and descriptions when it thinks there is a better one to use but by and large it will take your hint as to what the page is about.” ok. what about Bing? if Google isn’t the only one? not that I care a whole lot about Bing/Yahoo/whatever but…

  • Gamelicker, 27 September 2011

    You are absolutely right. The trouble of many webmasters around here is that they are trying to “get rich quick” and lack patience and focus. Many people think that they can only rank well if they use some “magic SEO system”. However the only way to rank well for a long time is to provide good content and create a community around your niche.

  • Robin Jennings, 27 September 2011

    Great round-up.

    I especially like the “No follow= not worth it”

    With some of the more advanced SEO tools they monitor follow vs. no follow.

    I imagine Mr. Google knows a lot more than they do and if you have a good mix of both it would show that you aren’t manipulating the system.

  • Tedel, 28 September 2011

    Hey, good article, but I’d appreciate another post mentioning some of the things that are still important in SEO as well.

  • Macdonald, 29 September 2011

    So, how would one know whether the advice given by any “expert” is actually good advice?

  • Michael Martine, 29 September 2011

    Useful stuff to be sure. If you’re gonna claim to bust myths, however, they should be real ones. PageRank is the only metric that matters? Really? Who the hell believes that? Not enough people to deserve to be called a myth that’s “bust-worthy,” that’s for sure. But definitely people are still arguing about the others you mention and so good job highlighting them.

  • Gustavo Macedo, 29 September 2011

    #11: True, but SEO + PPC increase the brand presence on the SERP. PPC also helps generate traffic for very specific keywords that have not yet gained relevance.

  • Judah Swagerty, 30 September 2011

    This is a really good article. Thank you for sharing it. Now I must repay the favor and share it with my network. Peace!

  • Aidan, 30 September 2011

    Great article. LOL – sitemaps, search engine submissions and keyword density – hah!

  • Orlando, 30 September 2011

    I heard most of these over my years. Way I look at it, just do what you know to do and you will rank. Like optimized site first!

  • C3M, 02 October 2011

    Good things, Great article

  • I wonder you did not quote Google’s default phrase related to SEO: “Create websites for people, no search engines!”

    On the other hand, quoting a one-liner does not make an article, so you’re excused… ;)

  • meenakshi, 04 October 2011

    Really it is fantastic.These are myths and clients have been pointing out to these myths.Writing for the users, defining functionality correctly, testing the website for validations have been able to bring forth the results for me as an SEO.

  • kayan, 05 October 2011

    Great writeup. Amazing some people think they can trick Google by stealing another website’s content (scraping), when Google is actually the best tool out there for discovering plagiarism. When text seems like it might be plagiarized, you can just do a quick Google with a suspicious sentence or two to find out where the text was taken from.

  • Wendy Owen, 06 October 2011

    Thanks James for putting these myths to rest. One thing you did not mention was frequency of content. I hear different opinions all the time about how often you should post on your site. I usually do it once a week for each site (original content), but not sure ig that’s enough.

    Thanks

  • Pulkit Kaushik | TheDolt, 15 October 2011

    Fantastic post. I am so glad I wasn’t doing anything wrong.

  • Werner Swiegers, 18 October 2011

    A fresh list for a change, good one.

  • Eric, 10 November 2011

    Thank you for the valuable information form above. I have been doing a bit of research about SEO and have learned a truck load from yours and many other articles about the topic. I am a designer and have recently decided to really go after building my company to something substantial. I could obviously not do it without the power of SEO.

    Thanks again, Eric

  • Elliott the web design guy, 17 November 2011

    On the button!! I’ve been having a discussion with other SEO consultants recently and this post backup everything I’ve been trying to put across – excellent post!

  • waqas, 20 November 2011

    Very well written & unique post. Keep posting

  • Matthew, 21 November 2011

    Nice article. This should back me up nicely with a current SEO debate I’m having with a client

  • arulmjoseph, 21 November 2011

    really i like your post thanks

  • Kimberly Gauthier, 30 December 2011

    When I started reading, I felt smart, because I’d figured a bit out; by the time I finished, I was rethinking my SEO strategies. Thanks for this great post!

  • Casey Camilleri, 16 February 2012

    Great post! You covered a ton of areas that would be great to know for someone just getting into SEO and learning what it’s all about and what it’s not about.

  • Sanju, 21 February 2012

    Explore the mysteries of SEO !!

  • David, 28 March 2012

    Useful list, goes over most of the aspects people fall foul of

  • Janez, 22 April 2012

    Great post, usefull pointers for SEO beginners.

search form
 
image description image description