What One Thing About Web Design Would You Change Today?
As Web designers and developers, much of our time is spent carving out little corners for ourselves: setting up stops along the information superhighway, creating hangouts to populate the virtual landscape. We shape areas of the Web as we choose to or as our clients command—like Neo altering the Matrix. Unlike Neo, though, we have rules to follow, standards to meet. Web development and design exist in a framework that dictates what we can and cannot do. With this idea of molding the Matrix in mind, we once again turned to our followers on Twitter.
In a recent poll, we asked: if you could make one thing about Web design different today, what would it be? To avoid repetition, we included a caveat: other than making IE disappear? With that, a wide range of answers flooded in on hash tags.[fblike]
As always, we appreciate everyone who took the time to respond to the poll. Having a strong connection with our readers is rewarding—that’s one thing about the Web design and development community that we hope never changes. Below is a peek at what Web development and design would be like if our Twitter followers and Facebook fans had their say in shaping the industry.
Even with the proviso in our question, most responses dealt with browsers—just not Internet Explorer. They also brought up how we build for the Web and how our work is interacted with, but browsers seemed to be the topic of the day. Judging by the amount of noise about it, the most frustrating problem is cross-compatibility between vendors. A number of different makers build browsers, and each browser has a unique way of rendering code; in this environment, designing and developing can be a burdensome task, and our readers would change it if they could.
Below are selected responses from our followers that offer a number of approaches to bettering the browser experience, and most of them deal with rendering code. There was variety in the responses, but making all browsers adhere to one set of enforced standards is an extremely popular solution. Compatibility was the focus.
- I’d make every browser standards-compliant… and every website look amazing!
- I would make every browser render the same code the same way.
- Kill vendor-specific codes. No more of this -webkit crap.
- Make all browsers be in sync. They are out of sync now. That’s the big difference between being a Web and graphic designer.
- As many have said, cross-browser standards. So much time is wasted creating cross-browser compatibility. I’d also like to see better methods for separating content and navigation forms.
- I’d ask all developers and companies to create one standard all-in-one Web browser. Need competition anyway? Here: plug-ins!
- All browsers should have a unified rendering engine.
- Standardize form elements across platforms and browsers.
- Force standards. The W3C should have to “allow” browsers to browse the Web—and if -webkit, -moz or 90% of IE’s browser-specific bullshit were there, they'd block the browser. In a week, we’d have development heaven for all.
- Make every browser read visual elements mathematically the same way so that developers wouldn’t have to care about cross-browsing.
- We need a single open-source rendering engine (i.e. WebKit) that every browser could use and contribute to—and then we can scrap all other engines.
- Fix font rendering.
Improving User Interfaces
What else would our readers like to tweak? Another fairly popular response had to do with making alterations to predominant user interfaces, to make them not only more user-friendly but more engaging than the standard ones we so often come across. A UI should never be taken lightly, because it leaves a stronger impression than the overall concept or content of the website itself. The design might be the most spectacular thing to ever grace an app or page, but if the interface hampers the experience, good luck getting people to come back.
We got a couple of suggestions that might steer the community toward a more advanced UI experience. From doing away with roll-over pop-ups to a website-specific history of links for returning users so that they can pick up where they left off, whatever the approach, adjusting the UI was in our readers’ sights.
- Oh bloody hell, that question is easy: NO roll-over popups. Anything that obscures content on the page should require a click!
- Engage people with better user interfaces, lightweight websites and Web apps in order to create great user experiences.
- Great design + great code = amazing experiences = happy people = a better world!
- I would like to see more usability functions and a “resume” option to bring up the last links seen on a website when you return to it. That way, if you have to leave, you can return and begin where you left off—a history, but saved on the server side of that specific website.
- Push for consistency and usability.
- I’d have two versions of websites: one with no ads at all, the other with ads, etc. The Internet user would have options.
Our Twitter friends also wanted to change the Web design community and foster a collaborative mentality that motivates the masses. Many innovative and exciting minds are working in the design field, and some believe that the best possible change would be if more designers came together to encourage a forward-thinking and creative environment. By working together, we could educate and strengthen the community, empower the honest and dedicated designers out there and relegate the con-artist crew to the fringes of the industry.
A handful of replies suggested that through the unity of designers, we could effectively guide the industry forward. This doesn’t mean we would all have to agree on everything and move in the same direction. It just means that a friendlier, more collaborative mindset could take the community to new heights.
- I would reduce hostile competition between designers and increase collaboration. IMO, too many designers do their own thing.
- Improve quality of and access to education relevant to the industry.
- I’d make some sort of service-level agreement compulsory so that clients could see those “free” and “cheap” website con men for exactly what they are.
Flash: Fix Or Farewell
The next item our followers targeted falls under a couple of the other categories we've already discussed, but a few people specifically addressed this platform, so we thought we should too: Flash. Some say fix it and keep it around, others say abandon it once and for all. We know the topic is divisive. On one hand, the platform has been used to create some truly inspired work; on the other, compatibility is not guaranteed. For that reason and others, some people have called for its head. Perhaps there could be a compromise, in the form of a stable and functional version that realizes its full potential.
The responses below make clear that both sides are passionate. Flash has done so much for the art and design communities that not giving it a nod would be wrong. Perhaps, though, that nod should be a final one as Flash quietly exits the playing field.
- I would kill Flash.
- Make Flash disappear.
- Somehow sort Flash so it integrates better. Don’t ever overlook what Flash has done for Web design and digital art!
Standards Approval And Implementation
Next up: the standards that govern the field. More specifically, let’s talk about the process by which those industry standards are approved and then universally put into practice. This does partially fall under the umbrella of browser issues, which kicked this article off. We felt we should also address the overly long time it takes for these standards to actually become standards. In this field, where staying ahead of the game and being as innovative as possible is all but mandatory, lags in the industry don’t help us break new ground.
Below are the responses in this part of the conversation. Speeding up the standards certification process would be a major step forward for the Web design community. Moreover, if the implementation happened across the board for all vendors simultaneously, all of our jobs would be so much simpler.
- I want instant adoption of CSS3 so we wouldn’t have to bother with so many vendor-specific rules.
- Web standards should be approved faster. By the time they are official, there’s a whole new language ready to take their place.
- Make Web fonts standardized and universal, starting immediately!
Modding the Box Model
We also thought it prudent to cover the box model and the way different vendors handle this element of Web-based projects. Much like the Flash dispute, there are a couple of different takes on this, and both turned up in the poll responses. Altering the box model math would work if all vendors, say, adopted the IE approach to setting margins and borders and padding around boxes. Rather than working outside the box like the other vendors (who require you to do math to set them), IE works inside the box to keep your
div the size you intended. An approach other than with IE would steer the industry away from the box model altogether and just push the grid.
This would provide some level of consistency among the various browsers. Alterations that simplify our work are always welcomed, and cutting out unnecessary steps from the process would be a change for the better.
- Change box-model math.
- Replace the box model with a grid model.
The next item we’ll examine also concerns a box of sorts, but this one metaphorical. It’s a box found in the minds of many industry creatives and otherwise innovative thinkers, and changing it would be amazing. If everyone could break free of their mental boxes (the ones they can’t think outside of), the industry would explode. We’d soar to fantastic heights and open up unforeseen trails. No-limit thinking should be a required study for everyone working in creative fields.
Hopefully, the advice offered below will help you break out of your box. Usually, the only reason we don’t try something new is because we haven’t seen it done before. That should be a reason to go forward, not back.
- Make your work free of limited thinking. Why a sidebar? Why a menu? Why a content area? Why not re-invent it all?! Free your mind!
How Design Is Perceived
The last topic that came up in the poll is the way our job is perceived by those outside of it, especially clients. It’s a problem that bothers many in the industry. Unfortunately, some belittle the creative process, undervaluing us and our work in the process. We often hear horror stories of designers being disrespected by former clients. It can make the job much more difficult than it should be. This would be a welcome change.
Easier said than done, but admitting there is a problem is always the first step to solving it. Opening a dialog on the subject, and keeping the tone respectful, is one way forward. Information is usually the best way to combat ignorance.
- Change the client’s ingrained perceptions of cost and value.
We say a final word of thanks to all who participated in the Twitter poll. Below are a few resources to check out when you have the time and inclination. Feel free to leave comments on what you would change about the world of Web design.
- The Web Standards Project
A grassroots coalition that fights for standards to ensure basic affordable access to Web technologies for all.
- World Wide Web Consortium (W3C)
An international community that develops standards to guide the long-term development of the Web.
- The Interactive CSS Box Model Demo
Just what you would expect. Get a look at the box model in action.
- The CSS Box Model
A comprehensive guide to the CSS box model for those interested in learning a bit more about it.
- 20 websites to Help You Master User Interface Design
A useful post that teaches you the basics (and more) of UI design.